2009/10/23
good, bad, and ugly of windows 7
I went ahead and installed it. Windows 7 is compelling, but still, it has been overhyped.
Good:
- I get the impression that most reviews became enamored with the new task bar, which, while compelling and does save a lot of time, is not entirely critical to me.
- If the tablet functions of Vista were its only must-have features, then the alternate input improvements are the key selling points of Windows 7 for me. Here we have much improved Chinese handwriting recognition and speech recognition (in particular, dictation) in multiple languages. These have passed the critical threshold of being useable and indeed I can say they are better than keyboard input. That is no small feat.
- Math input panel, as mentioned previously, is not quite up to par yet, but I can see a lot of potential. While it is faster than typing straight LaTeX, it is not faster than LyX. But for labeling figures, this is perhaps useful.
- PowerShell, i.e. Monad, is beautiful.
- The volume controller has been restored to usefulness, with audio loopback for devices now possible.
- Libraries could be a very useful feature, but seems to be lacking something that helps ease their management.
- Per-file versioning (from system restore) should be very helpful.
Bad: